Andy Pettitte
on eBay
Search for anything on eBay and this page will show the next 200 items closing soonest. Use the Overnight Search Box to see what auctions are closing over the next 7 days and because there is less exposure in the middle of the night there will be some great deals to be had. Use the overnight auction tool to browse auctions and bid in advance via search or by using the pre-made search pages in the menu's above.
Auctions Soon
No Bids
2h - 52m - 8s
$40.00
Yankees 2022 ANDY PETTITTE BOBBLEHEAD Collectible #2 SGA 6/10/22 NEW IN BOX
No Bids
10h - 15m - 29s
$75.00
2022 Topps Pristine Andy Pettitte Slice of a Star Auto Orange Refractor /25
No Bids
13h - 12m - 16s
$0.99
1995 Upper Deck Minor League Top Prospect #176 Andy Pettitte Clippers Yankees
No Bids
14h - 31m - 15s
$1.29
(20 Card Lot) 2007 Upper Deck #340 Andy Pettitte - Houston Astros / NY Yankees
No Bids
14h - 44m - 11s
$0.99
Andy Pettitte 3 Card MLB Baseball Trading Card Lot Yankees Astros A&G Mini
With 3 Bids
15h - 57m - 42s
$29.53
2022 Topps Pristine-Slice of the Star Auto Relics Andy Pettitte #SSAR-AP AU, MEM
No Bids
16h - 37m - 41s
$2.25
Andy Pettitte New York Yankees 2025 Panini Prizm Premium Box Set Break #1
No Bids
17h - 7m - 58s
$19.99
ANDY PETTITTE - Refractor 1998 Topps Finest - PSA 9 - POP 3 - 1 Higher - YANKEES
With 2 Bids
17h - 14m - 49s
$2.34
2002 Topps Gold Label Andy Pettitte MLB Awards Ceremony Jersey Class 1 #ACR-AEP
No Bids
17h - 36m - 26s
$1.25
Andy Pettitte 2025 Panini Prizm (SP) Green Ice Prizm #234 New York Yankees
No Bids
17h - 40m - 5s
$14.99
NY Yankees Card Lot Rivera Jeter Judge Dominguez Ruth Winfield HOF RC Fan Faves
No Bids
18h - 5m - 32s
$9.99
Andy Pettitte /225 ⚡💎- 2005 Bowman Chrome - SUPER REFRACTOR - Astros - Yankees
No Bids
18h - 23m - 45s
$14.99
NY Yankees Card Lot Rivera Bernie Deion Winfield O’Neill Gehrig HOF/RC/Fan Faves
No Bids
19h - 16m - 56s
$14.99
🏆 NY Yankees Card Lot Mantle Rivera Rizzo Bernie Tino - HOF/RC/Fan Favorites
With 7 Bids
19h - 37m - 42s
$10.50
2017 Bowman Chrome MLB Draft History Andy Pettite RC /99 BGS 9.5 w/ 10 AUTO
No Bids
19h - 47m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte/Ruben Rivera 1995 Topps #640 - On Deck - RC - Yankees - Gem Mint
No Bids
19h - 49m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte/Ruben Rivera 1995 Topps #640 - On Deck - RC - Yankees - Gem Mint
With 2 Bids
19h - 56m - 41s
$1.25
ANDY PETTITTE 2025 PANINI PRIZM BASEBALL BLACK GOLD NEW YORK 5/5 Q3599
No Bids
19h - 58m - 11s
$14.99
🔥 NY Yankees & Knicks Mixed Card Lot Jeter Mantle Clemens - Ewing Oakley Starks
With 1 Bid
20h - 34m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte 1995 Select ARTIST PROOF #163 - RC - Yankees - RARE - Gem Mint
No Bids
20h - 48m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte 1996 Fleer Ultra GOLD MEDALLION #104 - RC - Yankees - Gem Mint
No Bids
21h - 3m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte 1997 Topps Season's Best HILL TOPPERS REFRACTOR #SB17 - Gem Mint
No Bids
21h - 9m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte 1997 Finest Competitors SILVER w/ Coating #287 Yankees - Gem Mint
No Bids
21h - 24m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte 1997 Fleer ZONE REFRACTOR #13 - Yankees - SUPER RARE - Gem Mint
No Bids
21h - 27m - 41s
$0.79
Andy Pettitte 1997 Fleer TEAM LEADER DIE-CUT #10 - New York Yankees - Gem Mint
No Bids
29h - 46m - 21s
$1.95
Andy Pettitte ROOKIE CARD 1993-94 Fleer Excel #111 Prince William Cannons (RC)
No Bids
32h - 28m - 26s
$15.00
2024 Topps Tribute Dual Relics Blue - Roger Clemens & Andy Pettitte #022/150
No Bids
34h - 35m - 41s
$9.95
Andy Pettitte 1997 Pinnacle Inside Baseball Pack in Factory Sealed Can Clean
No Bids
35h - 47m - 35s
$9.99
New York Yankees Christmas Ornament 2007-Derek Jeter, A-Rod, Andy Pettitte HTF
No Bids
36h - 2m - 38s
$89.99
2025 Topps ANDY PETTITTE (Astros) *FLAGSHIP AUTOGRAPH/PATCH* TFAP2-AP #04/10
No Bids
36h - 9m - 14s
$0.99
#29 Andy Pettitte - NY Yankees - 1998 Donruss Studio Oversized 8" x 10" Portrait
No Bids
37h - 50m - 50s
$15.00
Andy Pettitte 2007 New York Yankee Post Pin Collection In Original Package
No Bids
40h - 9m - 22s
$11.77
2003 BOWMAN BASEBALL FACTORY SEALED HOBBY PACK LOT OF (7) SEALED HOBBY PACKS
With 2 Bids
41h - 38m - 37s
$1.25
Andy Pettitte #4 Art Card Limited 45/50 Edward Vela Signed (New York Yankees)
No Bids
41h - 44m - 26s
$4.00
Andy Pettitte ROOKIE CARD 1993-94 Fleer Excel #111 Prince William Cannons (RC)
No Bids
41h - 58m - 17s
$1.29
1996 ANDY PETTITTE Upper Deck Major League Debut Insert #144 New York Yankees RC
No Bids
42h - 12m - 33s
$75.00
2024 Topps Major League Material Andy Pettitte Auto Red #/25 SSP RARE Yankees
No Bids
42h - 19m - 27s
$1.25
2002 Fleer MLB Authentix Andy Pettitte New York Yankees #135 Free Shipping
No Bids
43h - 27m - 41s
$0.14
Andy Pettitte 1996 Donruss #74 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
No Bids
44h - 14m - 29s
$20.00
1996 Yankees World Series Champions Plaque With Andy Pettitte & Doc Gooden Cards
No Bids
53h - 0m - 8s
$9.25
VHS 2003 “Heading For Home” Baseball All-Stars Pedro Martinez Andy Pettitte MLB
No Bids
53h - 51m - 16s
$0.99
(2) 1996 TOPPS-PAUL O'NEILL # 284 & ANDY PETTITTE # 378 BASEBALL CARDS (YANKEES)
No Bids
56h - 21m - 36s
$7.99
Andy Pettitte Astros Pitcher Official Baseball Card #95 2005 Mint Condition
No Bids
56h - 51m - 22s
$5.00
2005 Donruss Throwback Threads - Andy Pettitte #PG-36 Ball Short 2 Base Hit /25
No Bids
58h - 46m - 48s
$15.00
2010 Topps Heritage 411 Core Four Posada Pettitte Mariano Rivera Jeter F03667
No Bids
59h - 19m - 27s
$0.99
2013 Topps NEW YORK YANKEES Baseball Team Set 17 Total Carda NEW - SEALED
No Bids
60h - 27m - 39s
$30.00
Derek JETER Bobblehead Andy PETTITTE Figure Trenton Thunder SGA Lot *Repaired*
No Bids
62h - 46m - 45s
$2.99
1998 Leaf Rookies Stars Ticket Masters #6 Derek Jeter & Andy Pettitte 1684/2500
No Bids
64h - 59m - 52s
$1.00
2021 TOPPS PRO DEBUT ANDY PETTITTE MILB-10 MILB LEGENDS PRINCE WILLIAM CANNONS
No Bids
65h - 24m - 41s
$2.99
2010 Topps Allen & Ginter's Cabinet Card #NCCB9 8x6 Ellsbury Pettitte Posada
With 1 Bid
65h - 26m - 18s
$6.00
Jesus Montero #TA-JMO /50 AU, RC) And Andy Pettitte Autographs New York Yankees
No Bids
65h - 36m - 1s
$44.99
2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Green /75 #FMA-AP Yankees
No Bids
66h - 44m - 21s
$39.99
Andy Pettitte - 1998 New York Yankees World Series Ring With Wooden Display Box
No Bids
66h - 56m - 10s
$0.99
2025 Panini Prizm ANDY PETTITTE Green Prizm SP New York Yankees HOF Legend
No Bids
66h - 58m - 13s
$10.00
MLB Star Players Vintage Card Lot (20) - Sabathia, Pettitte, Dawson, Prior
No Bids
66h - 58m - 34s
$10.00
MLB Star Players Vintage Card Lot (20) - Bernie, Gooden, Sandberg, Piazza
With 1 Bid
66h - 59m - 12s
$0.99
2024 Topps Tribute Roger Clemens Andy Pettitte Dual Relics Jersey Purple #/50
No Bids
66h - 59m - 13s
$2.50
Andy Pettitte 1997 Pacific Baseball Gold Crown Die Cuts #CG12 New York Yankees
No Bids
67h - 23m - 41s
$0.14
Andy Pettitte 1995 Select #163 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
No Bids
68h - 7m - 12s
$6.99
ANDY PETTITTE 1997 Collectors Choice Autographed card w/ Authentic Signature
No Bids
68h - 31m - 4s
$12.00
Vintage Factory Sealed 1994 Score MLB Baseball Series 1 (Gold Rush Card)🔥
No Bids
69h - 15m - 41s
$0.79
Derek Jeter/Andy Pettitte 1997 Fleer Ultra DOUBLE TROUBLE #7 Yankees - Gem Mint
No Bids
71h - 1m - 48s
$39.99
Mariano Rivera 100th K 6/16/96 Indians @ Yankees Ticket Stub Andy Pettitte W #23
No Bids
81h - 2m - 35s
$11.99
ANDY PETTITTE 2012 Topps Gypsy Queen GU JERSEY Relics Patch SP #GQR-AP YANKEES
No Bids
81h - 12m - 23s
$5.99
1997 Metal Universe Andy Pettitte PLATINUM PORTRAIT #8 of 10 - New York Yankees
No Bids
83h - 14m - 59s
$1.00
Andy Pettitte / Roger Clemens 2022 Panini Absolute Historical Duals #HD-RA
No Bids
84h - 41m - 23s
$18.00
New York Yankees Lot Over 100 Cards Past/Present Babe Ruth Jeter Judge Rookies
No Bids
87h - 11m - 6s
$0.60
1996 SP Andy Pettitte New York Yankees #130 Upper Deck Baseball Combined Shiping
With 5 Bids
89h - 36m - 41s
$15.50
ANDY PETTITTE 2025 TOPPS TIER ONE TALENT AUTOGRAPH GREEN A AUTO /20 Q4450
No Bids
89h - 42m - 16s
$2.25
Andy Pettitte New York Yankees 2025 Panini Prizm Premium Box Set Break #2
Andy Pettitte
on eBay
Auctions Soon
You searched for Andy Pettitte Auctions Ending Soon on eBay - You can also search using the Overnight Search Box and bid early on possible late closing bargains. The Overnight Listing Time starts at 12pm Eastern (9pm Pacific) until 10am Eastern (7am Pacific) and will reset to the next Day's Overnight Listings at 9am Eastern.
The search boxes will take wildcards to narrow your search, see below for usage.
Refine Your Search
Exclude Words:
Add a dash before the word you wish to exclude.
Example: Babe Ruth -base
This would show all the Babe Ruth results except Listings with the word Base in the title.
Search Multiple:
Put search terms in brackets with each one separated by a comma and space.
Example: (Derek Jeter, Wayne Gretzky, Wembanyama)
You can also use multiple filters at once:
Example: (Funko Pop)(Autographed, Limited) -batman
Example: (Chrome, Sapphire) Baseball Autograph -base
Example: (Action Figure)(Wrestling, WWE) -hogan -loose
Example: (Vintage)(Sign, Enamel Sign, Oil Sign) -coke -pepsi -neon
Some searches or premade pages may produce more than the maximum 200 results, refine your search to see all listings.
© Breakninja.com - 2025