Search for anything on eBay and this page will show the next 200 items closing each night over the next 7 days and because there is less exposure in the middle of the night there will be some great deals to be had. Use the overnight auction tool to browse auctions and bid in advance via search or by using the pre-made search pages in the menu's above.
Andy Pettitte
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
No Bids
8h - 5m - 52s
$20.00
New York Yankees Lot (90 Cards) Past/Present Babe Ruth Jeter Judge Rookies
No Bids
9h - 46m - 11s
$99.99
2022 Topps Five Star - Autographs Andy Pettitte #FSA-AP (AU) 1/1 One Of One Gold
No Bids
13h - 5m - 9s
$29.99
570+ New York Yankees Vintage Cards - Mantle Ruth Mattingly Guidry Griffey Berra
No Bids
13h - 26m - 34s
$20.00
HUGE Yankees LOT 82 Cards AARON JUDGE #d SP 50/50 Jeter-Mattingly-Past Present
No Bids
14h - 14m - 21s
$0.99
1996 Fleer ROOKIE SENSATION Andy Pettitte #14 - New York Yankees - Lot143
With 9 Bids
15h - 15m - 56s
$12.50
Massive New York Yankees Card Lot! Rookies, Stars, Inserts, Prospects MLB
No Bids
17h - 23m - 22s
$150.00
Andy Pettitte The Danbury Mint New York Yankees Statue Figure Original Box
With 2 Bids
17h - 59m - 0s
$1.25
2023 Topps Series 1 - 1988 Topps Baseball Relics Andy Pettitte #88R-AP (MEM)
No Bids
18h - 2m - 17s
$0.99
872: 2024 Topps T206/206 Online Exclusive Sweet Caporal Parallel Andy Pettitte
No Bids
18h - 20m - 42s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte Houston Astros 2025 Topps Series 2 Jumbo 5X Case 30X Box Break #5
No Bids
18h - 51m - 15s
$1.99
Andy Pettitte 2025 Topps Series 2 Baseball Hobby - 1X Case Player BREAK #11
No Bids
19h - 16m - 4s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte - 2025 Topps Sterling Baseball Hobby 1X Case Player BREAK #1
No Bids
19h - 58m - 21s
$1.99
1997 SkyBox E-X2000 - Star Date 2000 Andy Pettitte #3 MLB New York Yankees Card
With 8 Bids
20h - 5m - 17s
$9.50
2021 Topps Clearly Authentic Andy Pettitte 1954 Reimagining Auto #20/50 Yankees
No Bids
20h - 19m - 21s
$3.50
2010 Topps Allen & Ginter's Cabinet Card #NCCB9 8x6 Ellsbury Pettitte Posada
No Bids
20h - 19m - 21s
$3.50
2010 Topps Allen & Ginter's Cabinet Card #NCCB9 8x6 Ellsbury Pettitte Posada
No Bids
21h - 52m - 22s
$0.99
ANDY PETTITTE RELIC PATCH /6 2022 LEAF IN THE GAME USED THE CATHEDRAL YANKEES
No Bids
21h - 53m - 22s
$0.99
ANDY PETTITTE RELIC PATCH /4 2022 LEAF IN THE GAME USED THE CATHEDRAL YANKEES
No Bids
0h - 15m - 4s
$20.00
New York Yankees LOT 37 Cards AARON JUDGE Autograph/100 Rare Inserts-Rookies
No Bids
8h - 38m - 11s
$20.00
1996 Yankees World Series Champions Plaque With Andy Pettitte & Doc Gooden Cards
No Bids
10h - 25m - 32s
$0.99
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 46 Career Wins #112 Andy Pettitte /150 Yankees
No Bids
14h - 44m - 57s
$6.99
McFarlane Series 10 MLB Andy Pettitte HOUSTON Astros White Jersey Action Figure
No Bids
16h - 36m - 27s
$0.99
1998 Leaf Andy Pettitte #25 State Representatives New York Yankees 4891/5000
No Bids
18h - 18m - 40s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte Houston Astros 2025 Topps Series 2 Jumbo 5X Case 30X Box Break #6
No Bids
18h - 51m - 13s
$1.99
Andy Pettitte 2025 Topps Series 2 Baseball Hobby - 1X Case Player BREAK #12
No Bids
18h - 55m - 2s
$49.95
1993 Bowman Andy Pettitte BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Rookie RC #103 New York Yankees
No Bids
18h - 56m - 54s
$1.19
2008 Upper Deck - Multi-Product Insert Yankee Stadium Legacy Andy Pettitte...
No Bids
19h - 6m - 37s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte - 2025 Topps Sterling Baseball Hobby 1X Case Player BREAK #2
No Bids
19h - 27m - 55s
$2.99
2022 Topps Paragons Of The Postseason Lot - Lot Of 4 See Pic Of Cards In Lot
With 1 Bid
19h - 37m - 44s
$0.99
2002 Upper Deck Andy Pettitte Mariano Rivera Yankee Dynasty Jersey #YJ-PR
No Bids
19h - 45m - 4s
$50.00
Andy Pettitte/Matt Dunbar/Ron Frazier Auto Prince William Cannon Baseball Lot
No Bids
19h - 48m - 1s
$9.00
MILB - NY Yankees/Trenton Thunder "Andy Pettitte" Figurine 2013 - NIB - SGA
No Bids
20h - 2m - 10s
$15.00
MILB - Trenton Thunder "Andy Pettitte" Bobblehead (Road) - 2011 - NIB - SGA
No Bids
20h - 2m - 56s
$15.00
MILB - Trenton Thunder "Andy Pettitte" Bobblehead (Home) - 2011 - NIB - SGA
No Bids
20h - 3m - 45s
$34.99
2025 Leaf Trading Company 1996 Season Leader Wins John Smoltz And Andy Pettit/15
With 3 Bids
20h - 8m - 21s
$3.68
2019 TOPPS TRIPLE THREADS RELICS COMBO MARIANO RIVERA/ANDY PETTITTE/DEREK JETER
No Bids
20h - 14m - 22s
$1.99
1998 SKYBOX EX 2001 BASEBALL SP #28 ANDY PETTITTE NEW YORK YANKEES NRMT-MT!!!
No Bids
20h - 19m - 22s
$12.99
1997 DONRUSS STUDIO GOLD PRESS PROOF SP #5 ANDY PETTITTE NEW YORK YANKEES /500
With 1 Bid
20h - 23m - 21s
$0.99
Andy Pettitte Game Used Tag Beckett 9.5 Jersey Fusion 2008 UD Yankee Legacy
No Bids
20h - 42m - 22s
$7.99
Andy Pettitte Astros Pitcher Official Baseball Card #95 2005 Mint Condition
No Bids
20h - 54m - 58s
$2.50
Andy Pettitte 1997 Pacific Baseball Gold Crown Die Cuts #CG12 New York Yankees
No Bids
20h - 57m - 21s
$199.99
Mariano Rivera Derek Jeter Andy Pettitte Mariano Final Game Bobblehead FOCO New
With 19 Bids
21h - 9m - 22s
$61.00
2021 Topps Sterling Strikes Andy Pettitte Yankees Dual GU Jersey AUTO 5/25 PSA 9
No Bids
21h - 39m - 51s
$199.99
1995 COLUMBUS CLIPPERS MILK CAPS TEAM ISSUE CARPENTER-ANDY PETTITTE POP 3 PSA 10
No Bids
21h - 41m - 51s
$49.99
1995 COLUMBUS CLIPPERS MILK CAPS TEAM ISSUE CARPENTER-ANDY PETTITTE POP 1 PSA 9
With 15 Bids
22h - 47m - 38s
$35.00
Andy Pettitte 2024 Topps Museum Momentous Jumbo Game Used Patch Auto /15 Yankees
No Bids
22h - 54m - 21s
$0.99
2023 Topps Black & White - ANDY PETTITTE #89 COLORED SP #5/49 - New York Yankees
No Bids
11h - 7m - 15s
$44.99
2022 Topps Pristine Andy Pettitte Pink Refractor #168 #’d/15 Astros Yankees
No Bids
11h - 22m - 40s
$40.00
Huge Lot 2002 2003 2004 2005 Topps Chrome Upper Deck Donruss Baseball Cards VTG
No Bids
13h - 53m - 20s
$65.49
2021 Topps Definitive Andy Pettitte Patch Relic Auto /50 PSA Graded Slab MINT
No Bids
18h - 18m - 22s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte Houston Astros 2025 Topps Series 2 Jumbo 5X Case 30X Box Break #7
No Bids
18h - 41m - 15s
$1.99
Andy Pettitte 2025 Topps Series 2 Baseball Hobby - 1X Case Player BREAK #13
No Bids
19h - 6m - 25s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte - 2025 Topps Sterling Baseball Hobby 1X Case Player BREAK #3
No Bids
19h - 12m - 17s
$0.99
2023 Topps Series 1 - CC Sabathia & Andy Pettitte - One-Two Punch Insert #12P-4
No Bids
19h - 14m - 21s
$45.00
2006 Fleer Ultra Baseball Gold Medallion Lot Of 88 Cards No Duplicates. See Pic
No Bids
19h - 15m - 21s
$45.00
2006 Fleer Ultra Baseball 277 Card Set 182/200 Base, 78/90 Inserts, 17x Lucky 13
No Bids
19h - 54m - 47s
$1.29
1996 ANDY PETTITTE Topps MLB Sports Card #378 Yankees All-Star Pitcher (NM-MT)
With 11 Bids
20h - 38m - 21s
$28.00
2024 TOPPS CHROME LEGENDS AUTO #CLAAPE ANDY PETTITTE /50 PSA 8 DNA AUTO 10
No Bids
23h - 32m - 26s
$1.00
1997 Upper Deck Collector's Choice League Leaders John Smoltz, Andy Pettitte #60
No Bids
7h - 21m - 44s
$1.99
1996 Upper Deck Baseball Strike Force #68 - Andy Pettitte - New York Yankees NM+
No Bids
11h - 32m - 21s
$0.99
Andy Pettitte NYY/HOU 2025 Topps SERIES 2 JUMBO 10 Case (60 Box) Player Break #2
No Bids
12h - 57m - 4s
$4.25
Andy Pettitte (3 card lot) Emperors of the Zone Red Parrallel 1990s&2000s Best
No Bids
15h - 12m - 21s
$0.99
1996 Fleer ROOKIE SENSATION Andy Pettitte #14 - New York Yankees - Lot146
No Bids
17h - 25m - 41s
$22.00
Andy Pettitte Jersey Fusion Card With Game Used Swatch (plus a free pack)
No Bids
17h - 28m - 41s
$2.00
🔥2004 Donruss Elite Passing The Torch Andy Pettitte/Whitey Ford #ED 031/250🔥
No Bids
18h - 18m - 10s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte Houston Astros 2025 Topps Series 2 Jumbo 5X Case 30X Box Break #8
No Bids
18h - 33m - 36s
$0.99
2010 Topps Chrome - National Chicle Chrome Andy Pettitte #CC10 Refractor /499
No Bids
18h - 41m - 14s
$1.99
Andy Pettitte 2025 Topps Series 2 Baseball Hobby - 1X Case Player BREAK #14
No Bids
19h - 6m - 55s
$2.49
Andy Pettitte - 2025 Topps Sterling Baseball Hobby 1X Case Player BREAK #4
No Bids
19h - 12m - 59s
$39.99
Mariano Rivera 100th K 6/16/96 Indians @ Yankees Ticket Stub Andy Pettitte W #23
No Bids
19h - 15m - 2s
$6.50
2004 Topps New York Yankees 24 Card Lot - Pettitte, Posada, Clemens & More!
No Bids
20h - 6m - 51s
$79.99
2024 Topps Triple Threads Andy Pettitte Auto “Southpaw”Relic 26/27 Yankees
No Bids
20h - 14m - 23s
$2.00
MLB - New York Yankees 2013 Pocket Schedule "Andy Pettitte" - NEW - VINTAGE
No Bids
20h - 17m - 14s
$3.00
MLB - New York Yankees 2014 Pocket Schedule "Andy Pettitte" - NEW - VINTAGE
No Bids
20h - 37m - 29s
$499.00
Andy Pettitte 1997 SkyBox E-X2000 Essential Credentials #/99 SSP #34 Bgs 8
No Bids
20h - 51m - 55s
$9.92
NEW YORK YANKEES ~ Andy Pettitte ~ Autograph ~ SIGNED ~ Official Baseball
No Bids
20h - 52m - 21s
$3.50
2019 Andy Pettitte Topps Series 1 (150th Commemorative Patch) New York Yankees
No Bids
20h - 59m - 33s
$0.99
ANDY PETTITTE , YANKEES 1992 CLASSIC BEST , MINOR LEAGUE ROOKIE CARD #286 RC
No Bids
21h - 51m - 19s
$9.99
1995 Select Andy Pettitte Artist's Proof #163 Rookie New York Yankees U2098
No Bids
21h - 54m - 34s
$49.00
2004 Donruss Elite Team Gold Yankees Jeter Clemens Pettitte Williams Jersey /100
No Bids
22h - 10m - 3s
$90.00
HUGE Yankees LOT 9 Cards JUDGE RC🔥Graded Jeter+More #d Inserts Autographs RARE
No Bids
23h - 12m - 36s
$20.00
HUGE Yankees LOT 36 Cards JUDGE #d Inserts RARE Rookies-Inserts🔥Invest Lot
No Bids
23h - 30m - 20s
$4.99
1997 Ultra Andy Pettitte / Derek Jeter Double Trouble #7 New York Yankees U2462
No Bids
2h - 28m - 53s
$1.75
2012 Topps Timeless Talents TT-12 Andy Pettitte Yankees and Cliff Lee Phillies
No Bids
11h - 12m - 52s
$20.00
HUGE Yankees LOT 35 Cards JUDGE #d Inserts RARE Rookies-Autographs🔥Invest Lot
No Bids
12h - 5m - 36s
$99.99
Huge (500+) Rare Yankees Refractor Pack 1st RC Insert Lot Jeter Mantle Judge +
No Bids
12h - 57m - 42s
$2.99
2004 Playoff Absolute Mem. TEAM TANDEMS Roger Clemens/Andy Pettitte /250 Astros
No Bids
15h - 39m - 27s
$5.99
ANDY PETTITTE 2004 Donruss Leather & Lumber with AUTOGRAPH Houston Astros
Andy Pettitte
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
You searched for Andy Pettitte on the eBay Overnight Auctions Tool. The Overnight Listing Time starts at 12pm Eastern (9pm Pacific) until 10am Eastern (7am Pacific) and will reset to the next Day's Overnight Listings at 9am Eastern.
The search boxes will take wildcards to narrow your search, see below for usage.
Refine Your Search
Exclude Words:
Add a dash before the word you wish to exclude.
Example: Babe Ruth -base
This would show all the Babe Ruth results except Listings with the word Base in the title.
Search Multiple:
Put search terms in brackets with each one separated by a comma and space.
Example: (Derek Jeter, Wayne Gretzky, Wembanyama)
You can also use multiple filters at once:
Example: (Funko Pop)(Autographed, Limited) -batman
Example: (Chrome, Sapphire) Baseball Autograph -base
Example: (Action Figure)(Wrestling, WWE) -hogan -loose
Example: (Vintage)(Sign, Enamel Sign, Oil Sign) -coke -pepsi -neon
Some searches or premade pages may produce more than the maximum 200 results, refine your search to see all listings.
© Breakninja.com - 2025