Search for anything on eBay and this page will show the next 200 items closing each night over the next 7 days and because there is less exposure in the middle of the night there will be some great deals to be had. Use the overnight auction tool to browse auctions and bid in advance via search or by using the pre-made search pages in the menu's above.
Andy Pettitte
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
No Bids
5h - 42m - 6s
$29.99
2001 Andy Pettitte Bobblehead (NY Yankees) World Series Edition Great Shape
No Bids
6h - 12m - 5s
$50.00
2006 Topps Finest GOLD Refractor #/49 Andy Pettitte RARE MINT +Gradable GEM !!
No Bids
7h - 53m - 24s
$45.00
2023 Topps Archives - 1969 Topps Team History Baseball Postcards Derek Jeter,...
No Bids
8h - 20m - 17s
$0.99
Andy Pettitte NYY 2025 Topps CHROME PLATINUM 100 BLASTERBox Player Break#1
No Bids
8h - 30m - 8s
$7.99
1996 Score New York Yankees 19 Card Lot Derek Jeter Rookie Boggs Mattingly Cone
No Bids
9h - 51m - 50s
$9.99
Panini Select 2025 Silver Wave Prizm Diamond Level Andy Pettitte Yankees #237
No Bids
10h - 4m - 58s
$5.00
1997 Collector's Choice All-Star Connection Lot Of 20 - Thomas, Bonds, Rodriguez
No Bids
10h - 34m - 59s
$125.00
Andy Pettitte Auto'd MLBaseball Steiner COA/Holo With MLB Holo #BB534439
No Bids
10h - 51m - 25s
$8.99
💥⚾️ 1997 ANDY PETTITTE NY New York Yankees Starting Lineup 10th Year, MLB ⚾️💥
No Bids
11h - 26m - 54s
$34.93
2003 DONRUSS TEAM HEROES BASEBALL FACTORY SEALED HOBBY PACK LOT OF (x10) PACKS
No Bids
11h - 57m - 41s
$8.00
Yankees Magazine April 2007 Andy Pettitte Cover Mariano Rivera Poster Included
No Bids
14h - 7m - 34s
$35.00
1995 TOPPS ANDY PETTITTE #640 ON DECK NEW YORK YANKEES ROOKIE RC PSA 9 MINT
No Bids
14h - 19m - 26s
$110.00
1993 Bowman Baseball Box New Sealed Possible Derek Jeter Andy Pettitte Rookie
With 2 Bids
14h - 29m - 17s
$2.25
1998 Pinnacle Zenith Jumbo: #Z24 Andy Pettite Gold Impulse /100 EX-EXMINT
With 2 Bids
14h - 54m - 22s
$0.40
Andy Pettitte 2013 Topps #90 Yankees MLB READ FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
No Bids
15h - 17m - 45s
$4.79
2003 Topps Gold /2003 lot CHIPPER JONES ANDY PETTITE Ben Grieve MINT NYY Braves
No Bids
15h - 21m - 17s
$295.00
2025 TOPPS CHROME LEGEND AUTO ORANGE REFRACTOR ANDY PETTITTE 13/25 PSA 10
With 4 Bids
15h - 26m - 1s
$15.50
2020 Panini Immaculate Extra Bases Quad Patch Auto Gold 3/10 Andy Pettitte
No Bids
16h - 21m - 17s
$149.99
1992 FLEER PROCARDS SIGNED ROOKIE CARD ANDY PETTITTE HORNETS YANKEES PSA DNA
With 1 Bid
16h - 25m - 19s
$0.01
Andy Pettitte 2010 Topps 206 #101 Yankees MLB READ FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
No Bids
18h - 31m - 27s
$0.01
Andy Pettitte 2020 Topps Archives #291 Astros MLB READ FREE SHIP AutographDen
No Bids
3h - 55m - 36s
$19.99
Andy Pettitte - 1998 New York Yankees World Series Ring With Wooden Display Box
No Bids
5h - 20m - 37s
$1.48
2025 Topps Update #FPU7 - Andy Pettitte - First Pitch Pink Foil Parallel - Yanks
No Bids
7h - 20m - 55s
$15.00
Andy Pettitte 2007 New York Yankee Post Pin Collection In Original Package
No Bids
9h - 28m - 6s
$79.00
2015 Panini National Treasures Andy Pettitte Treasured Materials Auto /25 RARE!
No Bids
10h - 13m - 35s
$1.29
(20 Card Lot) 2007 Upper Deck #340 Andy Pettitte - Houston Astros / NY Yankees
No Bids
10h - 49m - 7s
$3.99
2004 MLB Showdown Andy Pettite Houston Astros Excellent Conditions ⚾️⚡️💥⚾️
With 3 Bids
14h - 7m - 2s
$2.25
2025 Panini National Treasures - Timeless Talents Signatures Andy Pettitte /49
With 7 Bids
14h - 16m - 2s
$7.50
2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Moments Auto Autograph #FMA-AP Yankees
No Bids
14h - 21m - 54s
$20.25
V26 2017 Bowman Chrome Refractors That Never Were #RTNWAP Andy Pettitte /499 -
No Bids
14h - 38m - 11s
$0.99
Classic Games 1994 All Star Andy Pettitte #28 Albany-Colonie Yankees BCCG 9
No Bids
14h - 39m - 55s
$30.00
McFarlane Sportspicks MLB Houston Astros pitchers 3 figures. Never opened
No Bids
14h - 40m - 31s
$24.99
LOT-ANDY PETTITTE 2013 GU JERSEY FUSION & 2006 A&G FRAMED YANKEES BASEBALL CARDS
No Bids
14h - 54m - 42s
$1.50
2007 Topps Allen & Ginter's Andy Pettitte #251 New York Yankees Baseball Card
No Bids
15h - 7m - 18s
$40.00
2022 Topps Tier One - Tier One Talent Autographs Andy Pettitte #T1TA-AP /10
No Bids
15h - 52m - 17s
$1.20
1998 Upper Deck SPx Finite Andy Pettitte #108 Serial #995/9000 New York Yankees
No Bids
16h - 14m - 17s
$104.99
2025 Leaf Bronx Legacy The Rivalry 12 Game Used Relics Booklet /3 Jeter Ortiz
No Bids
17h - 8m - 44s
$9.99
Andy Pettitte 2013 NY Yankees Statue Figurine PC Richard & Son Promo w/ Box
No Bids
17h - 11m - 49s
$399.00
Andy Pettitte 1997 SkyBox E-X2000 Essential Credentials #/99 SSP #34 Bgs 8
No Bids
19h - 34m - 34s
$0.01
Andy Pettitte 2010 Topps 206 #101 Yankees MLB READ FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
With 4 Bids
2h - 28m - 18s
$53.00
1993 Bowman Baseball FACTORY SEALED Box 24 Packs Jeter, Pettitte, Jones RC's
With 8 Bids
3h - 5m - 15s
$152.50
2022 Topps Tripple Threads Baseball DRC-4 Deca Relic Combo Book Yankees 8/10
No Bids
5h - 45m - 42s
$0.99
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones ANDY PETTITTE 127/150 Career Wins N.Y. Yankees
No Bids
7h - 46m - 43s
$0.99
1999 Finest Andy Pettitte #208 Baseball card, New York Yankees. Flawed corner
No Bids
8h - 30m - 33s
$75.00
Bronx Legacy October Legends Jeter,Williams,Clemens,Torre,Posada, Petite,Rivera.
No Bids
8h - 50m - 17s
$0.99
Andy Pettitte NYY 2025 Topps CHROME PLATINUM 3 Case (36Box) Player Break#2
No Bids
8h - 53m - 31s
$3.99
1996 Upper Deck Statistic Leaders & Award Winners Box Set Open 23 Jumbo Cards
With 2 Bids
9h - 27m - 55s
$1.25
2008 UD Ballpark Collection Six Swatch Memorabilia Randy Halladay Smoltz Pettite
No Bids
10h - 31m - 2s
$3.00
2023 Topps Series 1 - 1988 Topps Baseball Relics Andy Pettitte #88R-AP (MEM)
No Bids
10h - 36m - 38s
$9.95
ROGER CLEMENS/ANDY PETTITTE-YANKEES--2024 MUSEUM COLLECTION--QUAD RELIC-08/10
No Bids
11h - 48m - 55s
$9.99
NEW YORK YANKEES 100 Card Lot ~ ALL DIFFERENT!! AARON JUDGE DEREK JETER VOLPE +
No Bids
13h - 6m - 17s
$0.49
2007 Topps Aleen & Ginter #185 TROY GLAUS Angeles Blue Jays NR MINT to MINT
No Bids
13h - 20m - 52s
$1.00
Andy Pettitte 2014 Topps Super Veteran Insert Card #SV-10 New York Yankees
With 2 Bids
13h - 58m - 18s
$1.25
2010 Topps Chrome - Jorge Posada - Blue Refractor /199 - New York Yankees
With 2 Bids
14h - 0m - 18s
$2.25
2003 Topps Chrome - Boomer David Wells - Blue Refractor /699 - New York Yankees
No Bids
14h - 2m - 41s
$3.99
(36) New York Yankees card lot- 1985-2024 Volpe Refractor /499, Lindgren Auto
No Bids
14h - 5m - 19s
$1.99
1998 Leaf - State Representatives Andy Pettitte #25 Serial #d 2125/5000 Yankees
No Bids
14h - 13m - 51s
$2.99
Topps Chrome Andy Pettitte Refractor/ base #43 Houston Astros 2006 MLB Card Lot
No Bids
14h - 21m - 39s
$1.28
27 of 1996 Fleer '96 Baseball Cards Lot. Nice Mixed Lot- Frank Thomas etc. LOOK!
No Bids
14h - 38m - 19s
$1.22
2025 Topps Allen & Ginter Mini Andy Pettitte #185 A&G Back SP Astros Yankees
No Bids
14h - 39m - 39s
$11.99
2013 Topps New York Yankees 17 Card Team Set-Jeter, Rivera Sabathia Fac Sealed
No Bids
14h - 44m - 42s
$0.75
1997 COLLECTOR'S CHOICE LEAGUE LEADERS #60- JOHN SMOLTZ / ANDY PETTITTE CARD
No Bids
14h - 53m - 53s
$29.99
1997 Pinnacle X-Press Gold Metal Works Andy Pettitte #17 Baseball Card #132/200!
With 8 Bids
15h - 12m - 17s
$18.50
ANDY PETTITTE 2025 TOPPS PRISTINE PIECES PATCH AUTO #PPAR-AP YANKEES Q6785
No Bids
15h - 12m - 48s
$0.99
1995 Upper Deck Minor League Andy Pettitte Yankees Top Prospect #176 WCG 10
No Bids
15h - 28m - 57s
$88.57
2025 PANINI FLAWLESS ACHIEVEMENTS SIGNATURES ANDY PETTITTE Silver #FAAP 10/20
No Bids
15h - 52m - 57s
$0.99
2010 Topps Heritage Chrome Refractor Andy Pettitte #C113 Serial 1160/1961
With 1 Bid
16h - 2m - 24s
$0.01
Andy Pettitte 2020 Topps Archives #291 Astros MLB READ FREE SHIP AutographDen
No Bids
16h - 15m - 5s
$99.99
2009 Topps Allen & Ginter Framed Cloth Andy Pettitte 06/10 - Rare - HTF Yankees
With 2 Bids
17h - 23m - 50s
$1.56
2010 Topps Heritage Core Four #411 New York Yankees, Derek Jeter, Rivera, Posada
Andy Pettitte
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
You searched for Andy Pettitte on the eBay Overnight Auctions Tool. The Overnight Listing Time starts at 12pm Eastern (9pm Pacific) until 10am Eastern (7am Pacific) and will reset to the next Day's Overnight Listings at 9am Eastern.
The search boxes will take wildcards to narrow your search, see below for usage.
Refine Your Search
Exclude Words:
Add a dash before the word you wish to exclude.
Example: Babe Ruth -base
This would show all the Babe Ruth results except Listings with the word Base in the title.
Search Multiple:
Put search terms in brackets with each one separated by a comma and space.
Example: (Derek Jeter, Wayne Gretzky, Wembanyama)
You can also use multiple filters at once:
Example: (Funko Pop)(Autographed, Limited) -batman
Example: (Chrome, Sapphire) Baseball Autograph -base
Example: (Action Figure)(Wrestling, WWE) -hogan -loose
Example: (Vintage)(Sign, Enamel Sign, Oil Sign) -coke -pepsi -neon
Some searches or premade pages may produce more than the maximum 200 results, refine your search to see all listings.
© Breakninja.com - 2026