When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.



 


MLB | NBA | NFL | NHL on
Overnight Auction Browser for Sports Cards
Check out the Overnight Auctions Tool and see all the Trading Cards for the next 7 days. Because they close in the late hours there will be some deals, bid in advance.

 

Big Picture Ebay Hits - Most Expensive - NHL - NHL Random - MLB - NFL - NBA


Ending Soonest with No Bids on Ebay - NHL - MLB - NFL - NBA

 

 

 

 

 

Indianapolis Colt Cards based on the Most Bids currently on Ebay, Top 100 results are shown below.

These cards will generally be the coolest hits for the team because of the amount of interest shown in them, if you are looking to buy some Indianapolis Colts cards then you came to the right place. From autographs to cool looking patches and game worn memorabilia, this team page should have them all.


Large Picture Ebay Cards
Products
Teams
Players

 

 

 

 

Ebay Logo


Peyton Manning Autographed signed on-field Indianapolis Colts NFL Helmet

Current Price $ 1125.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 14 H 41 M 33 S


🐎Peyton Manning Signed Indianapolis Colts Mitchell & Ness Throwback Jersey -NFL

Current Price $ 999.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 8 D 6 H 43 M 35 S


Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts Mythical Black Pandora /25 PSA 10 *POP 2*

Current Price $ 969.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 19 H 23 M 16 S


🏈Quenton Nelson SIGNED GAME ISSUED (2024 Season) Indianapolis Colts Nike Jersey

Current Price $ 769.22

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 11 H 45 M 8 S


2 Indianapolis Colts VS Miami Dolphins Tickets

Current Price $ 750.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 4 H 20 M 10 S


🏈Ryan Kelly Signed GAME WORN 10/06/22 Indianapolis Colts On-Field Jersey - NFL

Current Price $ 689.97

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 12 H 14 M 34 S


2 Indianapolis Colts VS Las Vegas Raiders Tickets

Current Price $ 625.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 5 H 1 M 17 S


2017 Panini Preferred #41 Andrew Luck SL JSY AU/5 Indianapolis Colts 2/5

Current Price $ 510.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 7 D 3 H 31 M 59 S


Marshall Faulk Autographed signed on-field Indianapolis Colts Helmet

Current Price $ 365.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 14 H 41 M 33 S


2018 Panini KABOOM! 💥 Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM MINT HOF SSP Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 332.00

Number of Bids: 19

Time Left - 5 D 11 H 15 M 33 S


Edgerrin James Signed Indianapolis Colts Salute To Service Authentic F/S Helmet

Current Price $ 300.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 9 H 52 M 12 S


Vintage Edgerrin James #32 Indianapolis Colts Reebok Jersey – Size 60/60.

Current Price $ 300.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 7 H 11 M 8 S


🏈Ryan Kelly Signed🖊️ Indianapolis Colts Full-Size Authentic Speed Helmet - NFL

Current Price $ 299.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 12 H 29 M 22 S


Marlon Mack Signed Indianapolis Colts 31x35 Custom Framed Jersey (JSA COA)

Current Price $ 189.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 13 H 2 M 23 S


Bulk sale, 100 vintage NFL Indianapolis Colts full size pennants, NM

Current Price $ 250.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 7 H 31 M 54 S


2024 Pro Set Anthony GOULD (RC) Autograph 1/1 REFRACTOR Indianapolis COLTS 1/1🔥

Current Price $ 250.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 4 H 54 M 23 S


Indianapolis Colts 10th Anniversary Jersey #85 Langhorn

Current Price $ 225.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 11 H 42 M 32 S


2000 UD Reserve Peyton Manning Buyback Auto #/6 Card #63 - Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 214.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 15 H 23 M 33 S


Anthony Richardson Signed Florida Gators Jersey (Beckett) Indianapolis Colts Q.B

Current Price $ 189.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 16 H 5 M 8 S


2022 Impeccable 1oz Silver Bar Alec Pierce /19 RC Auto Rookie Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 179.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 7 D 17 H 19 M 16 S


Sports Illustrated August 12 1991 Eric Dickerson Indianapolis Colts CGC 8.0

Current Price $ 175.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 16 H 39 M 0 S


Indianapolis Colts #20 Mike Doss Authentic Jersey

Current Price $ 175.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 10 H 19 M 16 S


December 20 2004 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts, Sports Illustrated CGC 8.5

Current Price $ 171.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 8 D 16 H 20 M 3 S


Indianapolis Colts NFL 46 Card Lot: Luck, Wayne, Dorsett, Hilton, & Ehlinger

Current Price $ 139.24

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 9 H 27 M 48 S


Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts 1994 Authentic 75yr Anniversary Patch Jersey

Current Price $ 149.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 10 H 43 M 3 S


Indianapolis Colts NFL Leather Jacket XL GIII Carl Banks ~ 2X Super Bowl Champs

Current Price $ 131.25

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 14 H 56 M 34 S


2021 Flawless Base Emeralds SSP #5/5 Michael Pittman Jr. Indianapolis Colts BG6

Current Price $ 144.25

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 16 H 51 M 33 S


2015 - 2016 Indianapolis Colts Signed NFL Football -Mathis, Luck, 12 signed case

Current Price $ 149.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 8 H 6 M 1 S


Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts Rookie Endorsements Auto /214 PSA 8

Current Price $ 129.20

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 5 H 17 M 8 S


Pat McAfee Autographed NFL Indianapolis Colts Football White Panel

Current Price $ 120.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 5 H 51 M 11 S


Marshall Faulk Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) NFL MVP 2000 / R.B.

Current Price $ 109.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 15 H 53 M 1 S


HOFer Coach TONY DUNGY INDIANAPOLIS COLTS Helmet No COA. Signed At A Event.

Current Price $ 100.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 7 H 31 M 55 S


nfl jersey new xl Indianapolis Colts Pat Mcafee Autographed

Current Price $ 99.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 3 H 47 M 15 S


2023 PANINI PRIZM ANTHONY RICHARDSON ORANGE ICE RC PSA 9 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS

Current Price $ 100.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 16 H 42 M 55 S


2008 FINEST MOMENTS PEYTON MANNING (LOW POP) INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 10 GEM-MINT

Current Price $ 99.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 7 D 9 H 43 M 49 S


Indianapolis Colts Authentic Jersey “Marshall Faulk”

Current Price $ 105.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 23 H 42 M 37 S


A Dwight Freeney Signed Jersey Indianapolis Colts PSA/DNA COA

Current Price $ 100.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 4 H 55 M 27 S


***RARE*** Indianapolis Colts 2007 Silverplate commemorative coin 1 of 1000

Current Price $ 100.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 13 H 33 M 15 S


2024 Press Pass Premium Football Anthony GOULD (XRC) /15 Indianapolis COLTS 🔥

Current Price $ 99.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 4 H 38 M 55 S


Dwight Freeney Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) 2002 1st Rd Drft Pk DE

Current Price $ 89.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 18 H 25 M 21 S


Andrew Luck Signed NFL Football Jersey Indianapolis Colts Nike A Large

Current Price $ 81.64

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 17 H 22 M 58 S


Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champion

Current Price $ 79.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 15 H 53 M 54 S


Dallas Clark Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Tight End Super Bowl XLI

Current Price $ 79.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 16 H 57 M 32 S


Zack Moss Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (Beckett) 2020 3rd Round Draft Pck RB

Current Price $ 79.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 18 H 42 M 26 S


Kwity Paye Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (Beckett) 2021 1st Round Draft Pk DE

Current Price $ 79.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 15 H 45 M 13 S


NWT VTG Peyton Manning #18 Indianapolis Colts Reebok Superbowl Patch Jersey 56

Current Price $ 79.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 7 H 47 M 15 S


PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS LEGEND Autograph/SIGNED Photo

Current Price $ 79.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 12 H 31 M 44 S


2024 Panini Optic Adonai Mitchell #343 Gold Ice RC /10 Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 79.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 18 H 55 M 1 S


Edgerrin James NFL Indianapolis Colts Autographed Item (JSA)

Current Price $ 80.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 5 H 0 M 52 S


Marlon Mack Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) 2017 4th Rd Pick / R.B.

Current Price $ 69.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 18 H 11 M 59 S


Jack Doyle Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) 2xPro Bowl Tight End

Current Price $ 69.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 15 H 46 M 47 S


Braden Smith Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) 2018 2nd rd Draft Pick

Current Price $ 69.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 17 H 11 M 23 S


Darius Leonard Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) 2018 2nd Rd Pick / LB

Current Price $ 69.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 18 H 20 M 6 S


NWT VTG Peyton Manning #18 Indianapolis Colts Reebok Superbowl Patch Jersey 56

Current Price $ 69.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 7 H 48 M 30 S


5/10 Jersey Match Anthony Richardson Auto Indianapolis Colts Football Card...

Current Price $ 75.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 14 H 37 M 34 S


Waterford Crystal 2007 Indianapolis Colts Super bowl XLI CHAMPIONS 🏈 . New

Current Price $ 79.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 3 H 9 M 24 S


Reebok Size 56 Indianapolis Colts Joseph Addai Football 🏈 Jersey

Current Price $ 68.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 23 H 13 M 29 S


Matt Ryan Signed Indianapolis Colts NFL Football Jersey Nike XL

Current Price $ 58.41

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 17 H 22 M 42 S


Matt Ryan Indianapolis Colts Signed NFL Football Jersey Adult XL

Current Price $ 58.24

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 17 H 23 M 13 S


Joseph Addai Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA Holo) Super Bowl XLI Champ RB

Current Price $ 59.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 16 H 45 M 40 S


Parris Campbell Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (Beckett COA) 2019 2nd Rd Pck

Current Price $ 59.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 17 H 38 M 50 S


NFL MARVIN HARRISON INDIANAPOLIS COLTS AUTOGRAPHED RIDDELL FOOTBALL MINI HELMET

Current Price $ 60.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 10 H 50 M 19 S


EDGERRIN JAMES SIGNED FLASH ALTERNATE INDIANAPOLIS COLTS MINI FOOTBALL HELMET

Current Price $ 59.95

Number of Bids: 1

Time Left - 2 D 8 H 56 M 55 S


Indianapolis Colts NFL Parris Campbell Signed Jersey Blue Beckett COA Rare

Current Price $ 66.66

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 15 H 36 M 29 S


1973 TOPPS # 56 LYDELL MITCHELL (ROOKIE) INDIANAPOLIS COLTS (RARE) PSA 8 NM-MT

Current Price $ 59.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 7 H 43 M 21 S


Mike Vanderjagt Autographed Indianapolis Colts 11x14 Photo With JSA COA

Current Price $ 64.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 14 H 41 M 33 S


Peyton Manning Signed 2009 Philadelphia #84 Card Indianapolis Colts HOF Auto AU

Current Price $ 59.00

Number of Bids: 12

Time Left - 1 D 16 H 3 M 44 S


Game Day NFL Indianapolis Colts Men’s Coat Puffer Jacket Blue Black Size XL

Current Price $ 49.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 19 H 57 M 43 S


Devin Funchess Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) U of Michigan W.R.

Current Price $ 49.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 16 H 30 M 19 S


Jacoby Brissett Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) 2016 3rd Rd Draft Pk

Current Price $ 49.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 16 H 34 M 52 S


Eric Ebron Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (Beckett COA) 2018 Pro Bowl T.E.

Current Price $ 49.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 17 H 25 M 0 S


Vintage Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts Wilson Authentic Pro Line Jersey Sz 50

Current Price $ 50.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 15 H 31 M 21 S


Players of the Century Johnny Unitas Indianapolis Colts Football Jersey Men M

Current Price $ 50.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 15 H 32 M 6 S


2022 Donruss Optic - Jelani Woods - Jazz Prizm SSP Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 55.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 17 H 29 M 29 S


2022 Donruss Optic - Jelani Woods - Jazz Prizm SSP Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 60.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 16 H 42 M 24 S


Indianapolis Colts Nike NFL On Field Apparel Pants Jeff Saturday Mens XL EUC

Current Price $ 59.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 11 H 44 M 25 S


2024 Leaf Vivid Adonai MITCHELL (RC) /5 Indianapolis COLTS REFRACTOR Card #104

Current Price $ 50.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 7 H 0 M 47 S


⚡️2024 Spectra ADONAI MITCHELL Gamma RC 8/8 Indianapolis Colts Splatter Neon!⚡️

Current Price $ 49.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 6 D 6 H 1 M 27 S


Indianapolis Colts Replica Helmet On Base,NFL Football Poly Helmet,New W/Box

Current Price $ 55.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 9 D 2 H 17 M 57 S


DWIGHT FREENEY Topps Vault 1/1 slide Syracuse Orange football Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 49.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 4 D 9 H 57 M 42 S


2023 Prizm #343 Anthony Richardson Lazer Rookie PSA 10 Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 49.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 8 H 20 M 43 S


Indianapolis Colts Signed Mini-Helmet JSA Certified - Lunar Eclipse

Current Price $ 44.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 10 H 36 M 36 S


2 Vintage Super Bowl XLI Pennants And 1967 Two Bar Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 40.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 15 H 19 M 48 S


Super Bowl XLIV Program Indianapolis Colts v. New Orleans Saints

Current Price $ 40.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 9 H 10 M 27 S


Indianapolis Colts Kwity Paye Autographed Mini Helmet -Beckett Certified

Current Price $ 45.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 4 H 17 M 48 S


Forever Collectibles - NFL 3D Logo Wall Plaque - Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 25.48

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 15 H 38 M 1 S


Jacoby Brissett Indianapolis Colts NFL Nike Jersey

Current Price $ 40.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 13 H 56 M 21 S


Youth Indianapolis Colts Jacket washed and Cleaned!

Current Price $ 40.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 3 D 4 H 4 M 15 S


2021 Contenders Rookie Ticket #246 Sam Ehlinger Auto PSA 8 Indianapolis Colts BG

Current Price $ 43.50

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 9 D 16 H 51 M 33 S


Lot of 18 Peyton Manning & Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards

Current Price $ 39.95

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 9 H 32 M 10 S


1998 Bowman #1 Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 9 RC Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 39.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 2 D 13 H 52 M 12 S


2009 SENIOR BOWL WEST VIRGINIA PATRICK McAFEE INDIANAPOLIS COLTS ROOKIE AUTO

Current Price $ 39.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 15 H 24 M 57 S


Dooney & Bourke Indianapolis Colts Football Team Wristlet Clutch Purse Wallet

Current Price $ 44.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 5 D 15 H 38 M 42 S


Vintage Wilson Authentic Indianapolis Colts Marshall Faulk 28 Jersey 42 Sewn

Current Price $ 30.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 0 D 13 H 7 M 24 S


Darius Leonard Indianapolis Colts Blue Football Jersey Signed-JSA Authenticated!

Current Price $ 29.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 7 D 14 H 17 M 32 S


2025 Custom McFarlane - Tyler Warren (#84) Indianapolis Colts Rookie Tight End

Current Price $ 29.99

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 9 D 16 H 24 M 39 S


1996 Indianapolis Colts team issued head shot set

Current Price $ 35.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 11 H 43 M 40 S


1997 Indianapolis Colts team issued head shot set

Current Price $ 35.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 11 H 44 M 2 S


INDIANAPOLIS COLTS NFL Riddell VSR Replica Football Helmet - Used

Current Price $ 26.00

Number of Bids: 6

Time Left - 3 D 12 H 11 M 37 S


MARVIN HARRISON Signed 8x10 Photo w/ Plaque and COA Indianapolis Colts

Current Price $ 30.00

Number of Bids: 0

Time Left - 1 D 15 H 41 M 33 S

 

 

 

Other Cool Football Links - Tonight's Case Breaks - Most Expensive Cards - Advanced Ebay Filter

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

Facebook Link for Breakninja.com

 

 

Baseball - Hockey - Football - Basketball - Entertainment - Reddit - Blog

 

 

Breakninja.com - 2025