Search for anything on eBay and this page will show the next 200 items closing each night over the next 7 days and because there is less exposure in the middle of the night there will be some great deals to be had. Use the overnight auction tool to browse auctions and bid in advance via search or by using the pre-made search pages in the menu's above.
Paul Oneill
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
No Bids
11h - 40m - 22s
$99.99
2024 Leaf Collective - Press Pass Paul O'Neill Autograph #PO1 1/1 Super Rare!!
No Bids
16h - 39m - 47s
$14.95
Graded Paul O'Neill Kal Daniels 1986 Fleer MLB Reds Prospects RC #646 CG 8.5 NM
No Bids
19h - 26m - 9s
$0.79
Paul O'Neill 1995 Fleer Ultra All-Stars GOLD MEDALLION #14 - Yankees - Gem Mint
No Bids
19h - 37m - 9s
$0.79
Kirby Puckett/Tony Gwynn/Paul O'Neill 1995 Donruss DOMINATORS #9 RARE - Gem Mint
With 3 Bids
19h - 46m - 53s
$13.50
2025 Topps Tier One Paul O'Neill Top Shelf Signatures #/75 Auto #TSS-PO Yankees
No Bids
20h - 29m - 9s
$0.79
Paul O'Neill 1995 Fleer Ultra All-Stars GOLD MEDALLION #14 - Yankees - Gem Mint
With 5 Bids
20h - 57m - 9s
$3.25
Paul O'Neill 1997 Bowman Chrome International REFRACTOR #82 - RARE - Gem Mint
No Bids
2h - 37m - 31s
$5.00
2005 Topps Pristine Legends Title Threads -PAUL O'NEAL- Game-Used Jersey #tt-po
No Bids
6h - 28m - 40s
$0.99
2021 TOPPS X DEREK JETER CAPTAIN'S CREW CARD NEW YORK YANKEES PAUL O'NEIL #32
No Bids
8h - 11m - 12s
$2.99
2003 Topps All-Time Fan Favorites - Paul O'Neill #124 New York Yankees HOF NM
No Bids
9h - 58m - 33s
$3.00
2024 Topps Allen & Ginter Yankees Paul O'Neill High # SP Gold Border Mini card
No Bids
10h - 24m - 51s
$49.95
2002 Topps Heart Of The Order Relics O'Neil/Williams/Martinez Graded CGC MT-9
No Bids
13h - 13m - 2s
$20.00
2024 Leaf Press Proof Paul Oneill Auto 1/4 Sp Red Refractor Shimmer Prizm New...
No Bids
13h - 45m - 3s
$25.00
2025 Topps Series 1 Paul O'Neill Auto Orange /25 New York Yankees #BSA2-PO
No Bids
16h - 39m - 11s
$1.00
1997 DONRUSS LEAF LIMITED COUNTERPARTS CARD #182 KLESKO / O'NEILL EX - AUG003
With 1 Bid
16h - 57m - 9s
$0.14
Paul O'Neill 1993 Studio #140 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
With 7 Bids
17h - 9m - 10s
$15.50
2023 Topps Chrome Black Paul O'neill On Card Autograph #CBA-PO Yankees
No Bids
18h - 21m - 29s
$59.99
Paul O'Neill Signed Rawlings Ball JSA. Plus Free Paul O’Neill Comm Foto Ball.
No Bids
5h - 25m - 55s
$249.99
2023 Leaf Trinity Trios Paul Skenes Mitch Jebb Oneil Cruz Auto 8/10 Pirates 🔥🔥
No Bids
5h - 32m - 44s
$0.99
(2) 1996 TOPPS-PAUL O'NEILL # 284 & ANDY PETTITTE # 378 BASEBALL CARDS (YANKEES)
No Bids
14h - 25m - 43s
$9.99
2024 Topps Archives - 1968 Topps Action All-Stars Autographs Paul O'Neill...
With 1 Bid
17h - 18m - 35s
$0.99
2025 Leaf Baseball Nation Paul O'Neill Pure Hitter Auto Sparkles Purple #6/7
With 1 Bid
17h - 39m - 41s
$0.99
2025 Panini Prizm Paul O'Neill - Blue Cracked Ice #139 New York Yankees
No Bids
17h - 53m - 36s
$31.99
2024 Topps Archives PAUL O'NEILL 1968 Action Auto Die-Cut On-Card Yankees
With 1 Bid
18h - 56m - 9s
$0.14
Paul O'Neill 1995 Select #131 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
With 1 Bid
19h - 18m - 9s
$0.14
Paul O'Neill 1994 Studio #216 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
No Bids
20h - 25m - 38s
$69.99
Paul O'Neill Signed 8x10 Photo New York Yankees Autograph JSA COA D13610
No Bids
5h - 54m - 41s
$75.00
2004 Upper Deck 56/100 Yankees Classic Script Dual Auto Paul O’NEILL/JIM LEYRITZ
No Bids
6h - 27m - 37s
$40.00
2025 Topps Tier One Top Shelf Signatures Card Paul O'Neill 49/49 eBay 1/1!!!!
No Bids
7h - 18m - 11s
$99.00
2025 Leaf Sports Heroes Paul O’Neill Magenta All Decade Team 1/1 Reds 🔥⚾️🔥
No Bids
7h - 40m - 38s
$10.00
St Louis Cardinals Autographed Baseball Paul Dejong, Tyler O’neill, Luis Garcia
No Bids
12h - 6m - 56s
$3.49
1996 Topps Finest Intimidator Refractor #93 Paul O'Neill OF New York Yankees MLB
No Bids
14h - 31m - 31s
$39.99
2003 Topps Admit One Farewell Riverfront Stadium O’Neill Cincinnati Reds FR-PO
With 2 Bids
17h - 14m - 9s
$1.25
PAUL O'NEILL 2025 TOPPS TIER ONE TOP SHELF SIGNATURES BLUE A AUTO /49 Q4450
With 1 Bid
17h - 39m - 10s
$3.00
2021 Topps Chrome Platnium Anniversary Red Atomic Refractor Paul O'neil /100
With 6 Bids
18h - 19m - 9s
$8.50
PAUL O'NEILL 2025 TOPPS TIER ONE TOP SHELF SIGNATURES YANKEES AUTO /75 Q4450
No Bids
18h - 39m - 10s
$2.39
1996 Leaf Signature Series New York Yankees Paul O'Neill SSP Gold Press Proof
With 1 Bid
18h - 51m - 9s
$0.99
2025 Leaf Baseball Nation Pure Hitter Clear Crystal Paul O'Neill 7/8 Auto
With 1 Bid
19h - 7m - 39s
$1.00
2025 Topps Tier One Paul O’Neill Top Shelf Signatures Auto Blue /49 Yankees
With 3 Bids
12h - 14m - 46s
$8.50
2022 Topps Five Star Auto Paul O’Neill - Yankees- World Series Champs 2025? 🔥🔥
No Bids
17h - 53m - 9s
$0.14
Paul O'Neill 1996 Bowman's Best #37 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
No Bids
20h - 11m - 52s
$109.95
Paul O' Neill Signed Cincinnati Reds Jersey (JSA COA) 5XWorld Series Champion
No Bids
20h - 59m - 7s
$3.99
1996 Topps Finest Sterling Silver Paul O’Neill 182 Nr. Mt.-Mt. Ungraded. Used.
No Bids
9h - 54m - 19s
$160.00
2025 Topps Baseball Stars Dual Auto Bernie Williams Paul O'Neill #BSDA2-ONW 8/10
No Bids
12h - 8m - 6s
$7.99
2008 SP Legendary Cuts Memorabilia Green Card #94/99 Paul O'Neill #LM-PO Yankees
No Bids
13h - 26m - 44s
$11.99
2008 SP Legendary Cuts Memorabilia Blue Card #36/99 Paul O'Neill #LM-PO Yankees
No Bids
16h - 22m - 46s
$1.65
1994 Donruss Special Edition Paul O'Neill #50 Ruben Sierra #33 Gary Sheffield #5
No Bids
17h - 48m - 49s
$49.00
1992 VINCETOWN SQUARE DISC PROOF RED BLUE USA VARIATION BUTTONS PAUL O'NEILL
No Bids
19h - 22m - 4s
$14.77
PAUL O'NEILL DUAL ROOKIE KAL DANIELS 1986 FLEER GMA 7 CARD CINCINNATI REDS RC
No Bids
20h - 21m - 19s
$0.99
2024 Topps Black & White #SS10 Paul O’Neil Shutter Speed Cincinnati Reds MLB
No Bids
4h - 53m - 4s
$0.99
(2) 1998 TOPPS STADIUM CLUB-PAUL O'NEILL # 104-DAVID WELLS # 75 BASEBALL CARDS
No Bids
10h - 37m - 14s
$0.99
1986 Donruss - Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 (RC) Ungraded EX/VG Cincinnati Reds
With 2 Bids
12h - 0m - 6s
$2.25
2023 Topps Platinum Anniversary Paul O’Neill gold wave refractor #38/50
No Bids
12h - 32m - 37s
$2.99
1993 O-Pee-Chee Premier Paul O'Neill New York Yankees Baseball Card #14 NM+
No Bids
14h - 5m - 42s
$7.99
2024 Topps Update Connor Phillips #MLMAU-CP Red Player-Worn Material 25/25 RC
No Bids
15h - 50m - 15s
$49.99
2022 Topps X Spotlight 70 II #57A Paul O’Neill Rainbow Foil Auto 1/5 POP 1
No Bids
16h - 5m - 57s
$49.99
2022 Topps X Spotlight 70 II #57 Paul O’Neill Red Back By Andy Friedman 6/10
No Bids
17h - 13m - 14s
$149.99
Paul O'Neill Signed 1996 Fitted Yankees Hat - " The Warrior" MAB Certified
No Bids
18h - 9m - 10s
$1.99
PAUL O'NEILL #68/99 2025 Panini Prizm Baseball Red Power Checkerboard Yankees
With 7 Bids
18h - 13m - 10s
$61.00
Pete Rose * Barry Larkin * Perez 2025 Leaf Sports Heroes Autograph Quad #7/7 SSP
No Bids
18h - 40m - 9s
$2.29
Paul O'Neill 2011 Topps Update #US316 Platinum Diamond Anniversary NY Yankees
No Bids
19h - 6m - 13s
$150.00
PSA 8 PAUL O'NEILL Auto ON-CARD Patch GAME USED - 2000 Upper Deck Game Jersey UD
No Bids
19h - 23m - 9s
$1.00
Paul O'Neill 2025 Leaf Metal Sports Heroes #BA-PO1 Auto Crystal Purple /15
No Bids
19h - 27m - 18s
$270.00
2023 Leaf Vivid - Colorful Combos Oneil Cruz, Paul Skenes #CCD-18 Red /8
With 1 Bid
18h - 41m - 24s
$4.97
1999 Bowman's Best PAUL O'NEILL Refractor /400 SP #36 NEW YORK YANKEES K911
No Bids
5h - 29m - 28s
$1.19
(3)1990 UPPER DECK PAUL O'NEILL # 161-ROB DIBBLE # 586-ERIC DAVIS # 116-BASEBALL
Paul Oneill
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
You searched for Paul Oneill on the eBay Overnight Auctions Tool. The Overnight Listing Time starts at 12pm Eastern (9pm Pacific) until 10am Eastern (7am Pacific) and will reset to the next Day's Overnight Listings at 9am Eastern.
The search boxes will take wildcards to narrow your search, see below for usage.
Refine Your Search
Exclude Words:
Add a dash before the word you wish to exclude.
Example: Babe Ruth -base
This would show all the Babe Ruth results except Listings with the word Base in the title.
Search Multiple:
Put search terms in brackets with each one separated by a comma and space.
Example: (Derek Jeter, Wayne Gretzky, Wembanyama)
You can also use multiple filters at once:
Example: (Funko Pop)(Autographed, Limited) -batman
Example: (Chrome, Sapphire) Baseball Autograph -base
Example: (Action Figure)(Wrestling, WWE) -hogan -loose
Example: (Vintage)(Sign, Enamel Sign, Oil Sign) -coke -pepsi -neon
Some searches or premade pages may produce more than the maximum 200 results, refine your search to see all listings.
© Breakninja.com - 2025