Search for anything on eBay and this page will show the next 200 items closing each night over the next 7 days and because there is less exposure in the middle of the night there will be some great deals to be had. Use the overnight auction tool to browse auctions and bid in advance via search or by using the pre-made search pages in the menu's above.
Don Mattingly
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
No Bids
3h - 2m - 43s
$3.89
2004 Playoff Prestige Achievements Don Mattingly #A2 NY Yankees Free Shipping
No Bids
4h - 2m - 23s
$1.09
(2) 1990 DON MATTINGLY-UPPER DECK # 191-FLEER # 447 BASEBALL CARDS (YANKEES)
No Bids
4h - 22m - 43s
$0.59
1985 & 1989 Donruss DON MATTINGLY DIAMOND KINGS BASEBALL CARDS EX/MT YANKEES
No Bids
4h - 48m - 11s
$1.25
1993 Leaf #237 Don Mattingly MLB Mister baseball trading card New York Yankees
No Bids
5h - 18m - 30s
$9.99
1995 Topps Finest Don Mattingly & Kenny Lofton Mint Condition, Outstanding Set
No Bids
5h - 43m - 23s
$5.00
1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly CGC 8.5 NM/M+; New York Yankees; MLB Baseball
No Bids
5h - 46m - 21s
$9.99
2023 Topps & Topps Chrome - 35th Anniversary Lot (17) - RC’s / Refractors / Mojo
No Bids
7h - 7m - 25s
$0.99
DON MATTINGLY - New York Yankees - 1993 Donruss Baseball MVP #5 - Insert Card
No Bids
8h - 29m - 18s
$12.99
MLB BASEBALL HOF ONLY LOT (55) Gwynn, Thomas, Griffey, Jackson, Henderson, Ryan
With 1 Bid
8h - 49m - 8s
$65.80
2024 Leaf Bronx Legacy /25 A Team For The Ages 8 Relics Munson Maris Mattingly
No Bids
10h - 2m - 43s
$5.00
New York Yankees Legends Card Lot (18)- HOF Jeter Mo Ruth Gehrig Mattingly More
No Bids
10h - 38m - 15s
$1.00
Don mattingly Winfield 1985 donruss 2 for the title baseball card in nrmt cond
No Bids
11h - 25m - 0s
$3600.00
SUPER RARE AUTOs MLB HOF LETTER ,MANTLE, AARON,RYAN,CARLTON,MATTINGLY ONEofONE
No Bids
11h - 48m - 25s
$0.99
Don Mattingly 1990 Fleer Base #638 Mark McGwire NY Yankees Oakland Athletics
With 12 Bids
11h - 59m - 0s
$26.00
1984 O-Pee-Chee OPC 8 Don Mattingly RC ROOKIE SGC 8 YANKEES CENTERED NO RESERVE
No Bids
12h - 20m - 3s
$23.99
1984 Topps Don Mattingly #8 PSA 7 - ROOKIE CARD - 6 Gland Slams in One Season!
No Bids
13h - 31m - 5s
$25.00
2003 UPPER DECK SWEET SPOT CLASSIC PINSTRIPES GAME WORN PANTS DON MATTINGLY
No Bids
13h - 39m - 9s
$5.99
Don Mattingly 1990 Sports Impressions Limited Porcelain Baseball Card w/ COA NIB
With 1 Bid
14h - 13m - 55s
$239.99
2024 Topps Museum Don Mattingly 1/1 Canvas Collection Original Art - Yankees
With 2 Bids
14h - 28m - 34s
$1.25
Lot Of 27 Rare Topps Micro Cards! Includes Jeter, Griffey, Ryan, Bonds, & More!
With 3 Bids
14h - 33m - 47s
$1.86
Don Mattingly #46 Art Card Limited 29/50 Edward Vela Signed (New York Yankees)
No Bids
15h - 7m - 24s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #20 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
15h - 11m - 49s
$1.50
LEGENDS MAYS/SCHMIDT/HENDERSON/MATTINGLY/GWYNN 2025 Series 1 1990 35th Anni
No Bids
15h - 25m - 3s
$1.98
Don Mattingly 2017 Topps 1985 AL MVP Award Winner Insert #23 Yankees MLB Legend
No Bids
15h - 35m - 55s
$1.98
Don Mattingly 2016 Topps Hallowed Highlights Insert #11 Yankees MLB Legend
No Bids
15h - 45m - 20s
$4.49
9 card oddball lof DON MATTINGLY Topps FINEST GQ Dream Team 3D For Record NICE+
With 1 Bid
15h - 51m - 0s
$39.99
Don Mattingly 38 Card Lot - 1984 Donruss #248 & 1984 Fleer #131 Rookie Yankees
No Bids
15h - 55m - 35s
$140.00
1998 DONRUSS SIGNIFICANT SIGNATURE DON MATTINGLY #534/2000 AUTO SGC 8.5 AUTO 10
No Bids
16h - 10m - 6s
$1.99
1994 Upper Deck Electric Diamond Home Field Advantage Don Mattingly #290 Yankees
No Bids
16h - 32m - 12s
$1.00
2025 Topps Series 1 - DON MATTINGLY - 1990 35th Anniversary Insert #T90-65
No Bids
16h - 40m - 51s
$4.99
Lot of 25: 1986 Topps Mini DON MATTINGLY Baseball Cards #28 ~ NM-MT+ ~ YANKEES ~
No Bids
16h - 47m - 1s
$3.00
2022 Topps Series 1 - 1987 Topps Baseball 35th Anniversary Don Mattingly #T87-13
No Bids
16h - 51m - 52s
$15.99
1 LB 9.7oz of MLB Baseball Card LOT, 80s-90s Inserts, Rookies, Stars, Commons
With 1 Bid
16h - 52m - 54s
$0.99
2020 Topps Project 2020 1984 Topps /7900 Don Mattingly - Gregory Siff #69
With 11 Bids
16h - 59m - 44s
$56.58
1984 Donruss 248 Don Mattingly RC ROOKIE SGC 8 YANKEES CENTERED NO RESERVE
No Bids
17h - 0m - 51s
$4.99
1994 DON MATTINGLY Topps Stadium Club GOLDEN RAINBOW #195 Yankess RARE MT ⚾️🔥
With 13 Bids
17h - 16m - 13s
$49.00
DON MATTINGLY 2002 UPPER DECK SWEET SPOT CLASSIC SIGNATURES AUTO Sgc 8.5
No Bids
17h - 16m - 26s
$1.99
1994 Upper Deck Don Mattingly SP Previews Eastern Region #ER4 New York Yankees
With 1 Bid
17h - 48m - 51s
$7.99
Sporting Life 2025 "Memorial Day 1/1"- DON MATTINGLY, New York Yankees Legend!
No Bids
18h - 2m - 2s
$1.49
Graig Biggio 89, Don Mattingly 89, Sammy Sosa 91, Chan Ho Park 94 4 Card Lot
With 4 Bids
18h - 5m - 30s
$3.21
Don Mattingly #76 Art Card Limited 30/50 Edward Vela Signed (New York Yankees)
No Bids
18h - 17m - 27s
$9.00
🟠⚾️2020 Topps A. & G. Set-Builder's Lot Of 108 Baseball Cards (SeeDescrp.For#s)
No Bids
18h - 17m - 50s
$0.99
2020 TOPPS GALLERY MASTER & APPRENTICE DON MATTINGLY/AARON JUDGE INSERT CARD
With 2 Bids
18h - 20m - 20s
$1.66
Don Mattingly #77 Art Card Limited 18/50 Edward Vela Signed (New York Yankees)
No Bids
18h - 20m - 54s
$7.99
Don Mattingly Baseball Card Lot 36 Cards Yankee All Star MVP Topps Fleer Donruss
No Bids
18h - 28m - 12s
$14.95
1991 Playball USA Don Mattingly LOT X 10 RARE !! New York Yankees Legend
No Bids
18h - 38m - 22s
$9.99
DON MATTINGLY 2005 New York Post Yankees Immortals Medallion Coin NIB RARE
No Bids
18h - 42m - 12s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #6 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
18h - 52m - 20s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #9 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
18h - 56m - 10s
$2.50
6-1986 Topps A.L. All Stars-Mattingly, Brett, Henderson, Fisk & 2 More- NM Cond.
No Bids
18h - 56m - 22s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #10 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
18h - 56m - 30s
$1000.00
2022 topps chrome triple player triple auto relic - rivera, jeter, mattingly
No Bids
19h - 4m - 33s
$0.75
DON MATTINGLY ROBERTO KELLY 1992 UPPER DECK #47 NEW YORK YANKEES NY Yankee Pride
No Bids
19h - 9m - 30s
$0.75
DON MATTINGLY 1988 DONRUSS DIAMOND KINGS INSERT #26 NEW YORK YANKEES NY MLB
No Bids
19h - 10m - 11s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #19 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
19h - 33m - 7s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #5 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
19h - 38m - 12s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #7 Don Maytingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
19h - 42m - 39s
$1.99
1990 TOPPS Don Mattingly #200 - New York Yankees - 1985 MVP - Six Time All-Star
No Bids
19h - 47m - 8s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #8 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
No Bids
20h - 0m - 13s
$0.55
1991 Line Drive #11 Don Mattingly NM+ Condition Combined Shipping Available
Don Mattingly
on eBay
Overnight Auctions
You searched for Don Mattingly on the eBay Overnight Auctions Tool. The Overnight Listing Time starts at 12pm Eastern (9pm Pacific) until 10am Eastern (7am Pacific) and will reset to the next Day's Overnight Listings at 9am Eastern.
The search boxes will take wildcards to narrow your search, see below for usage.
Refine Your Search
Exclude Words:
Add a dash before the word you wish to exclude.
Example: Babe Ruth -base
This would show all the Babe Ruth results except Listings with the word Base in the title.
Search Multiple:
Put search terms in brackets with each one separated by a comma and space.
Example: (Derek Jeter, Wayne Gretzky, Wembanyama)
You can also use multiple filters at once:
Example: (Funko Pop)(Autographed, Limited) -batman
Example: (Chrome, Sapphire) Baseball Autograph -base
Example: (Action Figure)(Wrestling, WWE) -hogan -loose
Example: (Vintage)(Sign, Enamel Sign, Oil Sign) -coke -pepsi -neon
Some searches or premade pages may produce more than the maximum 200 results, refine your search to see all listings.
© Breakninja.com - 2025